设计模式之原型模式以及深浅拷贝的区别

103 阅读8分钟

原型模式也是创建对象的一种方式,它一般用在这样的场景:系统中存在大量相同或相似对象的创建问题,如果用传统的构造函数来创建对象,会比较复杂而且耗费资源。这个时候使用原型模式的克隆方式,能够节省不少时间。比如Java 类中提供的Object clone()就是原型模式的应用。

一、原型模式介绍

原型设计模式(Prototype Design Pattern)指用一个已经创建的实例作为原型,通过复制该原型对象来创建一个和原型相同或相似的新对象。在Java语言中就存在克隆的方式,比如浅拷贝和深拷贝。

对于一般的对象创建,本身不会花费太多的资源,但是对于负责的对象,比如对象的数据需要经过复杂的计算才能得到(比如排序、计算哈希值),抑或是需要从 RPC、网络、数据库、文件系统等非常慢速的IO中读取,这个时候就可以利用原型模式从其他对象直接拷贝,从而减少资源的消耗。

二、原型模式的实现

在Java中原型模式的实现方式就是深拷贝和浅拷贝,下面来谈谈深拷贝和浅拷贝的区别

2.1 深拷贝和浅拷贝

2.1.1 浅拷贝

浅拷贝(Shadow Clone)是把原型对象中的成员变量为值类型的属性都复制给克隆对象,将为引用类的引用地址复制给克隆对象:

实现代码如下:

//实现Cloneable接口public class ShadowCopy implements Cloneable{    private String name;    private int id;    public String getName() {        return name;    }    public void setName(String name) {        this.name = name;    }    public int getId() {        return id;    }    public void setId(int id) {        this.id = id;    }    public ShadowCopy(String name, int id) {        this.name = name;        this.id = id;    }    @Override    protected Object clone() throws CloneNotSupportedException {        return super.clone();    }}//调用测试public class PrototypeTest {    public static void main(String[] args) throws CloneNotSupportedException {        ShadowCopy shadowCopy = new ShadowCopy("ethan", 01);        ShadowCopy copy = (ShadowCopy) shadowCopy.clone();        System.out.println("name:" + copy.getName() + " " + "id:" + copy.getId());        System.out.println(copy == shadowCopy);    }}

最后的测试结果copy == shadowCopy显示为false,说明为浅拷贝。我们再看看深拷贝:

2.1.2 深拷贝

深拷贝(Deep Clone)是将原型对象中的所有对象,无论值类型还是引用类型,都复制一份给拷贝对象:

那么深拷贝该如何实现?而且前面我们发现,在拷贝时为何需要重写 Object的 clone方法?先来看看其源码,发现clone方法是一个本地方法:

/**     * Creates and returns a copy of this object.  The precise meaning     * of "copy" may depend on the class of the object. The general     * intent is that, for any object {@code x}, the expression:     * <blockquote>     * <pre>     * x.clone() != x</pre></blockquote>     * will be true, and that the expression:     * <blockquote>     * <pre>     * x.clone().getClass() == x.getClass()</pre></blockquote>     * will be {@code true}, but these are not absolute requirements.     * While it is typically the case that:     * <blockquote>     * <pre>     * x.clone().equals(x)</pre></blockquote>     * will be {@code true}, this is not an absolute requirement.     * <p>     * By convention, the returned object should be obtained by calling     * {@code super.clone}.  If a class and all of its superclasses (except     * {@code Object}) obey this convention, it will be the case that     * {@code x.clone().getClass() == x.getClass()}.     * <p>     * By convention, the object returned by this method should be independent     * of this object (which is being cloned).  To achieve this independence,     * it may be necessary to modify one or more fields of the object returned     * by {@code super.clone} before returning it.  Typically, this means     * copying any mutable objects that comprise the internal "deep structure"     * of the object being cloned and replacing the references to these     * objects with references to the copies.  If a class contains only     * primitive fields or references to immutable objects, then it is usually     * the case that no fields in the object returned by {@code super.clone}     * need to be modified.     * <p>     * The method {@code clone} for class {@code Object} performs a     * specific cloning operation. First, if the class of this object does     * not implement the interface {@code Cloneable}, then a     * {@code CloneNotSupportedException} is thrown. Note that all arrays     * are considered to implement the interface {@code Cloneable} and that     * the return type of the {@code clone} method of an array type {@code T[]}     * is {@code T[]} where T is any reference or primitive type.     * Otherwise, this method creates a new instance of the class of this     * object and initializes all its fields with exactly the contents of     * the corresponding fields of this object, as if by assignment; the     * contents of the fields are not themselves cloned. Thus, this method     * performs a "shallow copy" of this object, not a "deep copy" operation.     * <p>     * The class {@code Object} does not itself implement the interface     * {@code Cloneable}, so calling the {@code clone} method on an object     * whose class is {@code Object} will result in throwing an     * exception at run time.     *     * @return     a clone of this instance.     * @throws  CloneNotSupportedException  if the object's class does not     *               support the {@code Cloneable} interface. Subclasses     *               that override the {@code clone} method can also     *               throw this exception to indicate that an instance cannot     *               be cloned.     * @see java.lang.Cloneable     */protected native Object clone() throws CloneNotSupportedException;

从注释可以知道,对于所有的对象来说:

  1. x.clone()!=x应当返回 true,因为克隆对象不能和原对象是同一个对象
  2. x.clone().getClass()==x.getClass()应当返回 true,因为克隆对象和原对象的类型是相同的
  3. x.clone().equals(x)应当返回true,因为使用equals方法比较时,其值都是相同的

Java 实现拷贝主要有两个步骤:一是实现 Cloneable空接口,二是重写Object的Clone方法后再调用父类的克隆方法super.clone(),那为何这样做?

拷贝功能不是一个常用的功能,因此在对象需要时实现即可,这样比较合理,而且在Java语言中一个类也可以实现多个接口。对于调用clone方法,因为该方法语义的特殊性,所以要有JVM的直接支持,而clone方法就是这个调用接口,一旦有类调用这个方法,就可以实现拷贝功能了。

2.1.3 深拷贝的实现方式

深拷贝的实现方式有很多种,大体上有这样几种:

1.所有对象都实现深拷贝

这种方式需要让类中所有引用对象都实现拷贝,从而实现类的深拷贝,代码如下:

public class CloneExample {    public static void main(String[] args) throws CloneNotSupportedException {        // 创建被赋值对象        Address address = new Address(110, "北京");        People p1 = new People(1, "Java", address);        // 克隆 p1 对象        People p2 = p1.clone();        // 修改原型对象        p1.getAddress().setCity("西安");        // 输出 p1 和 p2 地址信息        System.out.println("p1:" + p1.getAddress().getCity() +                " p2:" + p2.getAddress().getCity());    }    /**     * 用户类     */    static class People implements Cloneable {        private Integer id;        private String name;        private Address address;        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getName() {            return name;        }        public void setName(String name) {            this.name = name;        }        public Address getAddress() {            return address;        }        public void setAddress(Address address) {            this.address = address;        }        public People(Integer id, String name, Address address) {            this.id = id;            this.name = name;            this.address = address;        }        /**         * 重写 clone 方法         * @throws CloneNotSupportedException         */        @Override        protected People clone() throws CloneNotSupportedException {            People people = (People) super.clone();            people.setAddress(this.address.clone()); // 引用类型克隆赋值            return people;        }    }    /**     * 地址类     */    static class Address implements Cloneable {        private Integer id;        private String city;        public Address(Integer id, String city) {            this.id = id;            this.city = city;        }        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getCity() {            return city;        }        public void setCity(String city) {            this.city = city;        }        /**         * 重写 clone 方法         * @throws CloneNotSupportedException         */        @Override        protected Address clone() throws CloneNotSupportedException {            return (Address) super.clone();        }    }}

2.通过构造方法实现深拷贝

如果构造方法的参数为基本数据类型或者字符串类型,直接进行赋值即可,如果是对象类型,则需要重新 new 一个对象,实现代码如下:

public class CloneExample2 {    public static void main(String[] args) {        Address address = new Address(100, "北京");        People people1 = new People(1, "ethan", address);        People people2 = new People(people1.getId(), people1.getName(), new Address(people1.getAddress().getId(), people1.getAddress().getCity()));            }    static class People {        private Integer id;        private String name;        private Address address;        public People(Integer id, String name, Address address) {            this.id = id;            this.name = name;            this.address = address;        }        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getName() {            return name;        }        public void setName(String name) {            this.name = name;        }        public Address getAddress() {            return address;        }        public void setAddress(Address address) {            this.address = address;        }    }    static class Address {        private Integer id;        private String city;        public Address(Integer id, String city) {            this.id = id;            this.city = city;        }        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getCity() {            return city;        }        public void setCity(String city) {            this.city = city;        }    }}

3.通过字节流实现深拷贝

可以通过 JDK 自带的字节流实现深拷贝的方式,是先将要原型对象写入到内存中的字节流,然后再从这个字节流中读出刚刚存储的信息,来作为一个新的对象返回,那么这个克隆对象和原型对象就不存在任何地址上的共享,实现代码如下:

public class CloneExample3 {    public static void main(String[] args) {        Address address = new Address(100, "北京");        People people1 = new People(1, "ethan", address);                //字节流拷贝对象        People people2 = StreamClone.clone(people1);            }        static class StreamClone {        public static <T extends Serializable> T clone(People obj) {            T cloneObj = null;            try {                //写入字节流                ByteArrayOutputStream byteArrayOutputStream = new ByteArrayOutputStream();                ObjectOutputStream objectOutputStream = new ObjectOutputStream(byteArrayOutputStream);                objectOutputStream.writeObject(obj);                objectOutputStream.close();                //分配内存,写入原始对象并生成新对象                ByteArrayInputStream byteArrayInputStream = new ByteArrayInputStream(byteArrayOutputStream.toByteArray());                ObjectInputStream objectInputStream = new ObjectInputStream(byteArrayInputStream);                //返回生成的新对象                cloneObj = (T) objectInputStream.readObject();                objectInputStream.close();            } catch (Exception e) {                e.printStackTrace();            }            return cloneObj;        }    }    static class People implements Serializable {        private Integer id;        private String name;        private Address address;        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getName() {            return name;        }        public void setName(String name) {            this.name = name;        }        public Address getAddress() {            return address;        }        public void setAddress(Address address) {            this.address = address;        }        public People(Integer id, String name, Address address) {            this.id = id;            this.name = name;            this.address = address;        }    }    static class Address implements Serializable {        private Integer id;        private String city;        public Integer getId() {            return id;        }        public void setId(Integer id) {            this.id = id;        }        public String getCity() {            return city;        }        public void setCity(String city) {            this.city = city;        }        public Address(Integer id, String city) {            this.id = id;            this.city = city;        }    }}

在利用字节流进行拷贝时,要注意每个对象必须实现 Serizlizable接口,标识自己可以被序列化,否则就会抛出(
java.io.NotSerizlizableException)异常。

4.通过Apache Commons Lang实现深拷贝#

相对于方法3,这个方法可以直接调用,实现代码如下:

People people2 = (People)SerizlizationUtils.clone(people1);//其他部分和方法3相同,省略

5.通过JSON工具类实现深拷贝

Gson gson = new Gson();People people2 = gson.fromJson(gson.toJson(people1), People.class);

在该方法中,不需要对People和Address类进行标识序列化。使用JSON 工具类会先把对象转化成字符串,然后再从字符串转化成新的对象,因此不会和原型对象有关联。从而实现了深度拷贝,其他类似的 JSON 工具类的实现方式也是如此。

三、总结

原型模式在 Java 中主要有两种实现方式:深拷贝和浅拷贝,两者区别是深拷贝会复制引用对象,浅拷贝只会复制引用对象的地址。深拷贝相对于浅拷贝更加耗时和资源。

为何有深拷贝的存在呢?因为对于可变对象来说,浅拷贝对于引用对象的地址拷贝会带来修改风险。所以在可变对象的场景下,尽量还是选择深拷贝的方式进行复制。