node servers大对比

327 阅读6分钟

本文对比了在node环境下建立后端服务的几种常用方式之间的区别,从便捷度、中间件、路由、异步、社区、受欢迎程度、websocket支持、性能、可扩展性和学习难度几个方面对它们做了细致的对比。

  1. 使用便捷度:

    • 本地 http 模块:需要手动处理许多细节,相对较繁琐。
    • express 包:非常简便易用,提供了高级抽象,使创建服务器和路由变得简单。
    • koa 包:也相对简便,但与 express 类似,提供了更多的中间件控制。
  2. 中间件支持:

    • 本地 http 模块:支持最低,需要手动处理所有中间件功能。
    • express 包:拥有广泛的中间件生态系统,可以轻松添加各种中间件。
    • koa 包:同样具有广泛的中间件支持,但与 express 不同的是它使用异步中间件。
  3. 路由:

    • 本地 http 模块:需要手动配置路由,较为繁琐。
    • express 包:内置支持路由,可轻松定义路由和处理程序。
    • koa 包:也内置支持路由,提供了强大的路由功能。
  4. Async/Await 支持:

    • 本地 http 模块:不支持异步/等待。
    • express 包:支持异步/等待,可以编写更具表现力的代码。
    • koa 包:同样支持异步/等待,鼓励使用异步中间件。
  5. 社区支持:

    • 本地 http 模块:社区支持有限。
    • express 包:活跃的社区,有大量的插件和资源可用。
    • koa 包:同样有活跃的社区,提供丰富的中间件和资源。
  6. 受欢迎程度:

    • 本地 http 模块:相对不受欢迎,因其复杂性而不常用。
    • express 包:非常受欢迎,被广泛采用。
    • koa 包:也受欢迎,尤其在异步场景中。
  7. HTTP/2 支持:

    • 本地 http 模块:需要手动配置以启用 HTTP/2。
    • express 包:内置支持 HTTP/2,可以轻松启用。
    • koa 包:同样内置支持 HTTP/2。
  8. WebSocket 支持:

    • 本地 http 模块:需要手动实现 WebSocket。
    • express 包:支持 WebSocket,可以使用中间件方式集成。
    • koa 包:同样支持 WebSocket,可通过中间件方式实现。
  9. 性能:

    • 本地 http 模块:性能相对较低,特别是在高负载情况下。
    • express 包:性能良好,但不如其他包那么轻量。
    • koa 包:性能良好,特别适用于异步代码。
  10. 可扩展性:

    • 本地 http 模块:可扩展性有限,需要自行处理大部分功能。
    • express 包:高度可扩展,具有丰富的中间件和插件。
    • koa 包:同样高度可扩展,支持异步中间件。
  11. 学习曲线:

    • 本地 http 模块:学习曲线较陡峭,需要深入了解 HTTP。
    • express 包:学习曲线适中,易于入门。
    • koa 包:同样学习曲线适中,但对异步编程有更高的要求。
特性本地 http 模块expresskoa其他知名包
使用便捷度中等简便简便各有不同
中间件支持最低广泛支持广泛支持各有不同
路由手动配置内置支持内置支持各有不同
Async/Await 支持各有不同
社区支持有限活跃活跃各有不同
受欢迎程度较不受欢迎非常受欢迎受欢迎各有不同
HTTP/2 支持手动配置各有不同
WebSocket 支持手动实现中间件方式中间件方式各有不同
性能低到中等良好良好各有不同
可扩展性有限各有不同
学习曲线较陡峭中等中等各有不同

English version

  1. Ease of Use:

    • Native http Module: Using the native http module requires manual configuration for routing, request handling, and response generation. It is considered less user-friendly for beginners.
    • express Package: express provides a high-level, easy-to-use framework for building web applications. It abstracts many low-level details, making it user-friendly.
    • koa Package: koa offers a simpler and more lightweight API compared to express, making it easy to use for building web applications.
    • Other Famous Packages: The ease of use varies among other packages, with some offering simplicity similar to express or koa, while others may have unique complexities.
  2. Middleware Support:

    • Native http Module: The native http module has minimal built-in middleware support, and you need to manually implement middleware if needed.
    • express Package: express offers extensive middleware support with many built-in middleware functions and the ability to create custom middleware easily.
    • koa Package: koa also provides extensive middleware support, and its middleware functions are more lightweight and flexible compared to express.
    • Other Famous Packages: Middleware support varies among other packages, with some having rich middleware ecosystems.
  3. Routing:

    • Native http Module: Routing in the native http module requires manual configuration using regular expressions or custom logic.
    • express Package: express has built-in routing with easy-to-define routes using HTTP methods and URL patterns.
    • koa Package: Similar to express, koa has built-in routing with middleware-like route handlers.
    • Other Famous Packages: Routing mechanisms differ among other packages, with some using similar approaches to express or koa.
  4. Async/Await Support:

    • Native http Module: The native http module lacks built-in support for async/await, making handling asynchronous operations more challenging.
    • express Package: express supports async/await out of the box, allowing for more readable asynchronous code.
    • koa Package: koa is designed around async/await, making it easy to handle asynchronous operations.
    • Other Famous Packages: Async/await support varies among other packages, with some adopting modern JavaScript features.
  5. Community Support:

    • Native http Module: The community support for the native http module is limited, with fewer community-contributed modules and resources.
    • express Package: express has an active and large community with abundant resources, tutorials, and third-party middleware.
    • koa Package: koa also has an active community, although it may be smaller than express.
    • Other Famous Packages: Community support varies depending on the popularity of each package.
  6. Popularity:

    • Native http Module: The native http module is less popular for building web applications compared to higher-level frameworks.
    • express Package: express is very popular and widely used for building web applications in Node.js.
    • koa Package: koa is popular, although it may have a slightly smaller user base compared to express.
    • Other Famous Packages: Popularity varies among other packages based on their unique features and use cases.
  7. HTTP/2 Support:

    • Native http Module: Enabling HTTP/2 support in the native http module typically requires manual configuration.
    • express Package: express provides built-in support for HTTP/2 with easier configuration.
    • koa Package: Similar to express, koa supports HTTP/2 with convenient configuration options.
    • Other Famous Packages: HTTP/2 support may vary among other packages, and manual configuration may be required.
  8. Websocket Support:

    • Native http Module: Implementing Websockets using the native http module requires manual coding and is more challenging.
    • express Package: Websocket support in express can be achieved using middleware but is not as straightforward as in other packages.
    • koa Package: Similar to express, Websocket support in koa can be implemented using middleware.
    • Other Famous Packages: Some packages may offer more straightforward Websocket support with dedicated modules.
  9. Performance:

    • Native http Module: Performance of the native http module is moderate and can be less efficient for complex applications.
    • express Package: express offers good performance for many use cases and is optimized for speed.
    • koa Package: koa also provides good performance and is known for its lightweight design.
    • Other Famous Packages: Performance varies among other packages depending on their implementation and optimizations.
  10. Extensibility:

  • Native http Module: The native http module has limited extensibility, and custom features require more effort to implement.
  • express Package: express is highly extensible with a robust ecosystem of middleware and extensions.
  • koa Package: koa is known for its extensibility, allowing developers to create custom middleware easily.
  • Other Famous Packages: Extensibility varies among other packages, with some offering rich extension mechanisms.
  1. Learning Curve:
    • Native http Module: The native http module has a steeper learning curve, especially for beginners, due to its low-level nature.
    • express Package: express has a moderate learning curve and is considered more accessible for developers.
    • koa Package: koa also has a moderate learning curve, and its lightweight design can make it easier to grasp.
    • Other Famous Packages: The learning curve for other packages depends on their specific design and complexity.
FeatureNative http Moduleexpress Packagekoa PackageOther Famous Packages
Ease of UseModerateEasyEasyVaries
Middleware SupportMinimalExtensiveExtensiveVaries
RoutingManualBuilt-inBuilt-inVaries
Async/Await SupportNoYesYesVaries
Community SupportLimitedActiveActiveVaries
PopularityLess PopularVery PopularPopularVaries
HTTP/2 SupportManual ConfigurationYesYesVaries
Websocket SupportManual ImplementationMiddlewareMiddlewareVaries
PerformanceLow to ModerateGoodGoodVaries
ExtensibilityLowHighHighVaries
Learning CurveSteeperModerateModerateVaries